The P323L substitution in the SARS-CoV-2 polymerase (NSP12) confers a selective advantage during infection
| Title: | The P323L substitution in the SARS-CoV-2 polymerase (NSP12) confers a selective advantage during infection |
|---|---|
| Authors: | Goldswain, Hannah; Dong, Xiaofeng; Penrice-Randal, Rebekah; Alruwaili, Muhannad; Shawli, Ghada T.; Prince, Tessa; Williamson, Maia Kavanagh; Raghwani, Jayna; Randle, Nadine; Jones, Benjamin; Donovan-Banfield, Iah; Salguero, Francisco J.; Tree, Julia A.; Hall, Yper; Hartley, Catherine; Erdmann, Maximilian; Bazire, James; Jearanaiwitayakul, Tuksin; Semple, Malcolm G.; Openshaw, Peter J. M.; Baillie, J. Kenneth; Carson, Gail; Alex, Beatrice; Andrikopoulos, Petros; Bach, Benjamin; Barclay, Wendy S.; Bogaert, Debby; Chand, Meera; Chechi, Kanta; Cooke, Graham S.; da Silva Filipe, Ana; de Silva, Thushan; Docherty, Annemarie B.; dos Santos Correia, Gonçalo; Dumas, Marc-Emmanuel; Dunning, Jake; Fletcher, Tom; Green, Christoper A.; Greenhalf, William; Griffin, Julian L.; Gupta, Rishi K.; Harrison, Ewen M.; Hiscox, Julian A.; Ho, Antonia Ying Wai; Horby, Peter W.; Ijaz, Samreen; Khoo, Saye; Klenerman, Paul; Law, Andrew; Lewis, Matthew R.; Liggi, Sonia; Lim, Wei Shen; Maslen, Lynn; Mentzer, Alexander J.; Merson, Laura; Meynert, Alison M.; Moore, Shona C.; Noursadeghi, Mahdad; Olanipekun, Michael; Osagie, Anthonia; Palmarini, Massimo; Palmieri, Carlo; Paxton, William A.; Pollakis, Georgios; Price, Nicholas; Rambaut, Andrew; Robertson, David L.; Russell, Clark D.; Sancho-Shimizu, Vanessa; Sands, Caroline J.; Scott, Janet T.; Sigfrid, Louise; Solomon, Tom; Sriskandan, Shiranee; Stuart, David; Summers, Charlotte; Swann, Olivia V.; Takats, Zoltan; Takis, Panteleimon; Tedder, Richard S.; Thompson, A. A. Roger; Thomson, Emma C.; Thwaites, Ryan S.; Turtle, Lance C. W.; Zambon, Maria; Hardwick, Hayley; Donohue, Chloe; Griffiths, Fiona; Oosthuyzen, Wilna; Donegan, Cara; Spencer, Rebecca G.; Norman, Lisa; Pius, Riinu; Drake, Thomas M.; Fairfield, Cameron J.; Knight, Stephen R.; Mclean, Kenneth A.; Murphy, Derek; Shaw, Catherine A.; Dalton, Jo; Girvan, Michelle; Saviciute, Egle; Roberts, Stephanie; Harrison, Janet; Marsh, Laura; Connor, Marie; Halpin, Sophie; Jackson, Clare; Gamble, Carrol; Plotkin, Daniel; Lee, James; Leeming, Gary; Wham, Murray; Clohisey, Sara; Hendry, Ross; Scott-Brown, James; Shaw, Victoria; McDonald, Sarah E.; Keating, Seán; Ahmed, Katie A.; Armstrong, Jane A.; Ashworth, Milton; Asiimwe, Innocent G.; Bakshi, Siddharth; Barlow, Samantha L.; Booth, Laura; Brennan, Benjamin; Bullock, Katie; Catterall, Benjamin W. A.; Clark, Jordan J.; Clarke, Emily A.; Cole, Sarah; Cooper, Louise; Cox, Helen; Davis, Christopher; Dincarslan, Oslem; Dunn, Chris; Dyer, Philip; Elliott, Angela; Evans, Anthony; Finch, Lorna; Fisher, Lewis W. S.; Foster, Terry; Garcia-Dorival, Isabel; Gunning, Philip; Jensen, Rebecca L.; Jones, Christopher B.; Jones, Trevor R.; Khandaker, Shadia; King, Katharine; Kiy, Robyn T.; Koukorava, Chrysa; Lake, Annette; Lant, Suzannah; Latawiec, Diane; Lavelle-Langham, Lara; Lefteri, Daniella; Lett, Lauren; Livoti, Lucia A.; Mancini, Maria; McDonald, Sarah; McEvoy, Laurence; McLauchlan, John; Metelmann, Soeren; Miah, Nahida S.; Middleton, Joanna; Mitchell, Joyce; Murphy, Ellen G.; Pilgrim, Jack; Reynolds, Will; Ridley, P. Matthew; Sales, Debby; Shaw, Victoria E.; Shears, Rebecca K.; Small, Benjamin; Subramaniam, Krishanthi S.; Szemiel, Agnieska; Taggart, Aislynn; Tanianis-Hughes, Jolanta; Thomas, Jordan; Trochu, Erwan; van Tonder, Libby; Wilcock, Eve; Zhang, J. Eunice; Flaherty, Lisa; Maziere, Nicole; Cass, Emily; Carracedo, Alejandra Doce; Carlucci, Nicola; Holmes, Anthony; Massey, Hannah; Murphy, Lee; McCafferty, Sarah; Clark, Richard; Fawkes, Angie; Morrice, Kirstie; Maclean, Alan; Wrobel, Nicola; Donnelly, Lorna; Coutts, Audrey; Hafezi, Katarzyna; MacGillivray, Louise; Gilchrist, Tammy; Adeniji, Kayode; Agranoff, Daniel; Agwuh, Ken; Ail, Dhiraj; Aldera, Erin L.; Alegria, Ana; Allen, Sam; Angus, Brian; Ashish, Abdul; Atkinson, Dougal; Bari, Shahedal; Barlow, Gavin; Barnass, Stella; Barrett, Nicholas; Bassford, Christopher; Basude, Sneha; Baxter, David; Beadsworth, Michael; Bernatoniene, Jolanta; Berridge, John; Berry, Colin; Best, Nicola; Bothma, Pieter; Chadwick, David; Brittain-Long, Robin; Bulteel, Naomi; Burden, Tom; Burtenshaw, Andrew; Caruth, Vikki; Chambler, Duncan; Chee, Nigel; Child, Jenny; Chukkambotla, Srikanth; Clark, Tom; Collini, Paul; Cosgrove, Catherine; Cupitt, Jason; Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa; Dark, Paul; Dawson, Chris; Dervisevic, Samir; Donnison, Phil; Douthwaite, Sam; Drummond, Andrew; DuRand, Ingrid; Dushianthan, Ahilanadan; Dyer, Tristan; Evans, Cariad; Eziefula, Chi; Fegan, Chrisopher; Finn, Adam; Fullerton, Duncan; Garg, Sanjeev; Garg, Atul; Gkrania-Klotsas, Effrossyni; Godden, Jo; Goldsmith, Arthur; Graham, Clive; Hardy, Elaine; Hartshorn, Stuart; Harvey, Daniel; Havalda, Peter; Hawcutt, Daniel B.; Hobrok, Maria; Hodgson, Luke; Hormis, Anil; Jacobs, Michael; Jain, Susan; Jennings, Paul; Kaliappan, Agilan; Kasipandian, Vidya; Kegg, Stephen; Kelsey, Michael; Kendall, Jason; Kerrison, Caroline; Kerslake, Ian; Koch, Oliver; Koduri, Gouri; Koshy, George; Laha, Shondipon; Laird, Steven; Larkin, Susan; Leiner, Tamas; Lillie, Patrick; Limb, James; Linnett, Vanessa; Little, Jeff; Lyttle, Mark; MacMahon, Michael; MacNaughton, Emily; Mankregod, Ravish; Masson, Huw; Matovu, Elijah; McCullough, Katherine; McEwen, Ruth; Meda, Manjula; Mills, Gary; Minton, Jane; Mirfenderesky, Mariyam; Mohandas, Kavya; Mok, Quen; Moon, James; Moore, Elinoor; Morgan, Patrick; Morris, Craig; Mortimore, Katherine; Moses, Samuel; Mpenge, Mbiye; Mulla, Rohinton; Murphy, Michael; Nagel, Megan; Nagarajan, Thapas; Nelson, Mark; Norris, Lillian; O?Shea, Matthew K.; Otahal, Igor; Ostermann, Marlies; Pais, Mark; Panchatsharam, Selva; Papakonstantinou, Danai; Paraiso, Hassan; Patel, Brij; Pattison, Natalie; Pepperell, Justin; Peters, Mark; Phull, Mandeep; Pintus, Stefania; Pooni, Jagtur Singh; Planche, Tim; Post, Frank; Price, David; Prout, Rachel; Rae, Nikolas; Reschreiter, Henrik; Reynolds, Tim; Richardson, Neil; Roberts, Mark; Roberts, Devender; Rose, Alistair; Rousseau, Guy; Ruge, Bobby; Ryan, Brendan; Saluja, Taranprit; Schmid, Matthias L.; Shah, Aarti; Shanmuga, Prad; Sharma, Anil; Shawcross, Anna; Sizer, Jeremy; Shankar-Hari, Manu; Smith, Richard; Snelson, Catherine; Spittle, Nick; Staines, Nikki; Stambach, Tom; Stewart, Richard; Subudhi, Pradeep; Szakmany, Tamas; Tatham, Kate; Thomas, Jo; Thompson, Chris; Thompson, Robert; Tridente, Ascanio; Tupper-Carey, Darell; Twagira, Mary; Vallotton, Nick; Vancheeswaran, Rama; Vincent-Smith, Lisa; Visuvanathan, Shico; Vuylsteke, Alan; Waddy, Sam; Wake, Rachel; Walden, Andrew; Welters, Ingeborg; Whitehouse, Tony; Whittaker, Paul; Whittington, Ashley; Papineni, Padmasayee; Wijesinghe, Meme; Williams, Martin; Wilson, Lawrence; Winchester, Stephen; Wiselka, Martin; Wolverson, Adam; Wootton, Daniel G.; Workman, Andrew; Yates, Bryan; Young, Peter; Emmett, Stevan R.; Digard, Paul; Matthews, David A.; Turtle, Lance; Darby, Alistair C.; Davidson, Andrew D.; Carroll, Miles W. |
| Publisher Information: | BioMed Central |
| Publication Year: | 2023 |
| Collection: | Cardiff University: ORCA (Online Research @ Cardiff) |
| Description: | BackgroundThe mutational landscape of SARS-CoV-2 varies at the dominant viral genome sequence and minor genomic variant population. During the COVID-19 pandemic, an early substitution in the genome was the D614G change in the spike protein, associated with an increase in transmissibility. Genomes with D614G are accompanied by a P323L substitution in the viral polymerase (NSP12). However, P323L is not thought to be under strong selective pressure.ResultsInvestigation of P323L/D614G substitutions in the population shows rapid emergence during the containment phase and early surge phase during the first wave. These substitutions emerge from minor genomic variants which become dominant viral genome sequence. This is investigated in vivo and in vitro using SARS-CoV-2 with P323 and D614 in the dominant genome sequence and L323 and G614 in the minor variant population. During infection, there is rapid selection of L323 into the dominant viral genome sequence but not G614. Reverse genetics is used to create two viruses (either P323 or L323) with the same genetic background. L323 shows greater abundance of viral RNA and proteins and a smaller plaque morphology than P323.ConclusionsThese data suggest that P323L is an important contribution in the emergence of variants with transmission advantages. Sequence analysis of viral populations suggests it may be possible to predict the emergence of a new variant based on tracking the frequency of minor variant genomes. The ability to predict an emerging variant of SARS-CoV-2 in the global landscape may aid in the evaluation of medical countermeasures and non-pharmaceutical interventions. |
| Document Type: | article in journal/newspaper |
| File Description: | application/pdf |
| Language: | English |
| Relation: | https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/id/eprint/159192/1/s13059-023-02881-5.pdf; Goldswain, Hannah, Dong, Xiaofeng, Penrice-Randal, Rebekah, Alruwaili, Muhannad, Shawli, Ghada T., Prince, Tessa, Williamson, Maia Kavanagh, Raghwani, Jayna, Randle, Nadine, Jones, Benjamin, Donovan-Banfield, Iah, Salguero, Francisco J., Tree, Julia A., Hall, Yper, Hartley, Catherine, Erdmann, Maximilian, Bazire, James, Jearanaiwitayakul, Tuksin, Semple, Malcolm G., Openshaw, Peter J. M., Baillie, J. Kenneth, Baillie, J. Kenneth, Semple, Malcolm G., Openshaw, Peter J. M., Carson, Gail, Alex, Beatrice, Andrikopoulos, Petros, Bach, Benjamin, Barclay, Wendy S., Bogaert, Debby, Chand, Meera, Chechi, Kanta, Cooke, Graham S., da Silva Filipe, Ana, de Silva, Thushan, Docherty, Annemarie B., dos Santos Correia, Gonçalo, Dumas, Marc-Emmanuel, Dunning, Jake, Fletcher, Tom, Green, Christoper A., Greenhalf, William, Griffin, Julian L., Gupta, Rishi K., Harrison, Ewen M., Hiscox, Julian A., Ho, Antonia Ying Wai, Horby, Peter W., Ijaz, Samreen, Khoo, Saye, Klenerman, Paul, Law, Andrew, Lewis, Matthew R., Liggi, Sonia, Lim, Wei Shen, Maslen, Lynn, Mentzer, Alexander J., Merson, Laura, Meynert, Alison M., Moore, Shona C., Noursadeghi, Mahdad, Olanipekun, Michael, Osagie, Anthonia, Palmarini, Massimo, Palmieri, Carlo, Paxton, William A., Pollakis, Georgios, Price, Nicholas, Rambaut, Andrew, Robertson, David L., Russell, Clark D., Sancho-Shimizu, Vanessa, Sands, Caroline J., Scott, Janet T., Sigfrid, Louise, Solomon, Tom, Sriskandan, Shiranee, Stuart, David, Summers, Charlotte, Swann, Olivia V., Takats, Zoltan, Takis, Panteleimon, Tedder, Richard S., Thompson, A. A. Roger, Thomson, Emma C., Thwaites, Ryan S., Turtle, Lance C. W., Zambon, Maria, Hardwick, Hayley, Donohue, Chloe, Griffiths, Fiona, Oosthuyzen, Wilna, Donegan, Cara, Spencer, Rebecca G., Norman, Lisa, Pius, Riinu, Drake, Thomas M., Fairfield, Cameron J., Knight, Stephen R., Mclean, Kenneth A., Murphy, Derek, Shaw, Catherine A., Dalton, Jo, Girvan, Michelle, Saviciute, Egle, Roberts, Stephanie, Harrison, Janet, Marsh, Laura, Connor, Marie, Halpin, Sophie, Jackson, Clare, Gamble, Carrol, Plotkin, Daniel, Lee, James, Leeming, Gary, Law, Andrew, Wham, Murray, Clohisey, Sara, Hendry, Ross, Scott-Brown, James, Shaw, Victoria, McDonald, Sarah E., Keating, Seán, Ahmed, Katie A., Armstrong, Jane A., Ashworth, Milton, Asiimwe, Innocent G., Bakshi, Siddharth, Barlow, Samantha L., Booth, Laura, Brennan, Benjamin, Bullock, Katie, Catterall, Benjamin W. A., Clark, Jordan J., Clarke, Emily A., Cole, Sarah, Cooper, Louise, Cox, Helen, Davis, Christopher, Dincarslan, Oslem, Dunn, Chris, Dyer, Philip, Elliott, Angela, Evans, Anthony, Finch, Lorna, Fisher, Lewis W. S., Foster, Terry, Garcia-Dorival, Isabel, Gunning, Philip, Jensen, Rebecca L., Jones, Christopher B., Jones, Trevor R., Khandaker, Shadia, King, Katharine, Kiy, Robyn T., Koukorava, Chrysa, Lake, Annette, Lant, Suzannah, Latawiec, Diane, Lavelle-Langham, Lara, Lefteri, Daniella, Lett, Lauren, Livoti, Lucia A., Mancini, Maria, McDonald, Sarah, McEvoy, Laurence, McLauchlan, John, Metelmann, Soeren, Miah, Nahida S., Middleton, Joanna, Mitchell, Joyce, Moore, Shona C., Murphy, Ellen G., Pilgrim, Jack, Reynolds, Will, Ridley, P. Matthew, Sales, Debby, Shaw, Victoria E., Shears, Rebecca K., Small, Benjamin, Subramaniam, Krishanthi S., Szemiel, Agnieska, Taggart, Aislynn, Tanianis-Hughes, Jolanta, Thomas, Jordan, Trochu, Erwan, van Tonder, Libby, Wilcock, Eve, Zhang, J. Eunice, Flaherty, Lisa, Maziere, Nicole, Cass, Emily, Carracedo, Alejandra Doce, Carlucci, Nicola, Holmes, Anthony, Massey, Hannah, Murphy, Lee, McCafferty, Sarah, Clark, Richard, Fawkes, Angie, Morrice, Kirstie, Maclean, Alan, Wrobel, Nicola, Donnelly, Lorna, Coutts, Audrey, Hafezi, Katarzyna, MacGillivray, Louise, Gilchrist, Tammy, Adeniji, Kayode, Agranoff, Daniel, Agwuh, Ken, Ail, Dhiraj, Aldera, Erin L., Alegria, Ana, Allen, Sam, Angus, Brian, Ashish, Abdul, Atkinson, Dougal, Bari, Shahedal, Barlow, Gavin, Barnass, Stella, Barrett, Nicholas, Bassford, Christopher, Basude, Sneha, Baxter, David, Beadsworth, Michael, Bernatoniene, Jolanta, Berridge, John, Berry, Colin, Best, Nicola, Bothma, Pieter, Chadwick, David, Brittain-Long, Robin, Bulteel, Naomi, Burden, Tom, Burtenshaw, Andrew, Caruth, Vikki, Chadwick, David, Chambler, Duncan, Chee, Nigel, Child, Jenny, Chukkambotla, Srikanth, Clark, Tom, Collini, Paul, Cosgrove, Catherine, Cupitt, Jason, Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa, Dark, Paul, Dawson, Chris, Dervisevic, Samir, Donnison, Phil, Douthwaite, Sam, Drummond, Andrew, DuRand, Ingrid, Dushianthan, Ahilanadan, Dyer, Tristan, Evans, Cariad, Eziefula, Chi, Fegan, Chrisopher, Finn, Adam, Fullerton, Duncan, Garg, Sanjeev, Garg, Sanjeev, Garg, Atul, Gkrania-Klotsas, Effrossyni, Godden, Jo, Goldsmith, Arthur, Graham, Clive, Hardy, Elaine, Hartshorn, Stuart, Harvey, Daniel, Havalda, Peter, Hawcutt, Daniel B., Hobrok, Maria, Hodgson, Luke, Hormis, Anil, Jacobs, Michael, Jain, Susan, Jennings, Paul, Kaliappan, Agilan, Kasipandian, Vidya, Kegg, Stephen, Kelsey, Michael, Kendall, Jason, Kerrison, Caroline, Kerslake, Ian, Koch, Oliver, Koduri, Gouri, Koshy, George, Laha, Shondipon, Laird, Steven, Larkin, Susan, Leiner, Tamas, Lillie, Patrick, Limb, James, Linnett, Vanessa, Little, Jeff, Lyttle, Mark, MacMahon, Michael, MacNaughton, Emily, Mankregod, Ravish, Masson, Huw, Matovu, Elijah, McCullough, Katherine, McEwen, Ruth, Meda, Manjula, Mills, Gary, Minton, Jane, Mirfenderesky, Mariyam, Mohandas, Kavya, Mok, Quen, Moon, James, Moore, Elinoor, Morgan, Patrick, Morris, Craig, Mortimore, Katherine, Moses, Samuel, Mpenge, Mbiye, Mulla, Rohinton, Murphy, Michael, Nagel, Megan, Nagarajan, Thapas, Nelson, Mark, Norris, Lillian, O?Shea, Matthew K., Otahal, Igor, Ostermann, Marlies, Pais, Mark, Palmieri, Carlo, Panchatsharam, Selva, Papakonstantinou, Danai, Paraiso, Hassan, Patel, Brij, Pattison, Natalie, Pepperell, Justin, Peters, Mark, Phull, Mandeep, Pintus, Stefania, Pooni, Jagtur Singh, Planche, Tim, Post, Frank, Price, David, Prout, Rachel, Rae, Nikolas, Reschreiter, Henrik, Reynolds, Tim, Richardson, Neil, Roberts, Mark, Roberts, Devender, Rose, Alistair, Rousseau, Guy, Ruge, Bobby, Ryan, Brendan, Saluja, Taranprit, Schmid, Matthias L., Shah, Aarti, Shanmuga, Prad, Sharma, Anil, Shawcross, Anna, Sizer, Jeremy, Shankar-Hari, Manu, Smith, Richard, Snelson, Catherine, Spittle, Nick, Staines, Nikki, Stambach, Tom, Stewart, Richard, Subudhi, Pradeep, Szakmany, Tamas https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/view/cardiffauthors/A165386I.html orcid:0000-0003-3632-8844 orcid:0000-0003-3632-8844, Tatham, Kate, Thomas, Jo, Thompson, Chris, Thompson, Robert, Tridente, Ascanio, Tupper-Carey, Darell, Twagira, Mary, Vallotton, Nick, Vancheeswaran, Rama, Vincent-Smith, Lisa, Visuvanathan, Shico, Vuylsteke, Alan, Waddy, Sam, Wake, Rachel, Walden, Andrew, Welters, Ingeborg, Whitehouse, Tony, Whittaker, Paul, Whittington, Ashley, Papineni, Padmasayee, Wijesinghe, Meme, Williams, Martin, Wilson, Lawrence, Cole, Sarah, Winchester, Stephen, Wiselka, Martin, Wolverson, Adam, Wootton, Daniel G., Workman, Andrew, Yates, Bryan, Young, Peter, Emmett, Stevan R., Digard, Paul, Matthews, David A., Turtle, Lance, Darby, Alistair C., Davidson, Andrew D., Carroll, Miles W. and Hiscox, Julian A. 2023. The P323L substitution in the SARS-CoV-2 polymerase (NSP12) confers a selective advantage during infection. Genome Biology 24 (1) , 47. 10.1186/s13059-023-02881-5 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-023-02881-5 file https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/id/eprint/159192/1/s13059-023-02881-5.pdf |
| DOI: | 10.1186/s13059-023-02881-5 |
| Availability: | https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/id/eprint/159192/; https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-023-02881-5 |
| Rights: | cc_by_4_0 |
| Accession Number: | edsbas.3F8ABE82 |
| Database: | BASE |