Network meta-analysis examining efficacy of components of cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia

Titel:	Network meta-analysis examining efficacy of components of cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia
Verfasser:	Steinmetz, Lisa ; Simon, Laura ; Feige, Bernd ; Riemann, Dieter ; Johann, Anna ; Ell, Johanna ; Ebert, David Daniel ; Baumeister, Harald ; Benz, Fee ; Spiegelhalder, Kai
Veröffentlicht:	Freiburg : Universität, 2024
Umfang:	1 Online-Ressource
Format:	E-Book
Sprache:	Englisch

alg: 52460272
001A    $06000:12-12-24 
001B    $01999:13-12-24 $t01:50:53.000 
001D    $06000:12-12-24 
001U    $0utf8 
001X    $00 
002@    $0Oax 
002C    $aText $btxt $2rdacontent 
002D    $aComputermedien $bc $2rdamedia 
002E    $aOnline-Ressource $bcr $2rdacarrier 
003@    $0524602727 
004P    $010.1016/j.cpr.2024.102507 
004U    $0urn:nbn:de:bsz:25-freidok-2587341 
006G    $01348592869 
006U    $024,O12 $f20241118 
007A    $01348592869 $aDNB 
009Q    $uhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102507 $xR 
009Q    $uhttps://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bsz:25-freidok-2587341 $xR 
009Q    $qapplication/pdf $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $xH 
010@    $aeng 
010E    $erda 
011@    $a2024 $n2024 
021A    $aNetwork meta-analysis examining efficacy of components of cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia 
028A    $BVerfasser $4aut $71213474116 $8Steinmetz, Lisa [Tp3] $9466634218 
028C    $BVerfasser $4aut $8Simon, Laura [Tp3] $9460401203 
028C    $BVerfasser $4aut $71094928585 $8Feige, Bernd [Tp3] $937775014X 
028C    $BVerfasser $4aut $7121328201 $8Riemann, Dieter$Z1958- [Tp3] $915273080X 
028C    $BVerfasser $#Johann, Anna F. $#Johann, Anna Friederike $#Johann, Anna Friederike Dorothee $4aut $71135787646 $8Johann, Anna$Z1981- [Tp3] $9404612482 
028C    $aEll $BVerfasser $dJohanna $4aut 
028C    $BVerfasser $#Ebert, David $#Ebert, David D. $#Ebert, D. $#Ebert, D. D. $4aut $7112267600X $8Ebert, David Daniel$Z1979- [Tp1] $9397423942 
028C    $BVerfasser $4aut $717373104X $8Baumeister, Harald$Z1974- [Tp3] $9297900749 
028C    $aBenz $BVerfasser $dFee $4aut 
028C    $BVerfasser $4aut $713631998X $8Spiegelhalder, Kai$Z1977- [Tp3] $9204465281 
033A    $pFreiburg $nUniversität 
034D    $a1 Online-Ressource 
037A    $aClinical psychology review. - 114 (2024) , 102507, ISSN: 1873-7811 
037I    $uhttp://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/access_rights/c_abf2 $fUnrestricted online access 
037J    $aOpen Access $2star $uhttp://purl.org/coar/access_right/c_abf2 $fUnrestricted online access 
045B    $a616.84 $ADNB $e23kdnb $Emaschinell gebildet $K0,13883 
045E    $c610 
046X    $aArchivierung/Langzeitarchivierung gewährleistet $5DE-101 
047I    $aAbstract: Cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (CBTsingle bondI) is recommended as first-line treatment for insomnia. CBT-I is a multi-component intervention comprising psychoeducation, sleep restriction, stimulus control, cognitive, and relaxation therapy. The relative efficacy of its components has yet to be investigated with state-of-the-art meta-analytic methods. PubMed, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, PsycARTICLES, and CINAHL were searched according to a pre-registered protocol using search terms indicative of insomnia and CBTsingle bondI. Baseline-to-post-treatment effect sizes (Cohen's d) were calculated in a component network meta-analysis. Eighty studies representing 15,351 participants (mean age 44.9 years, 70.1 % female) were included. For the primary outcome insomnia severity, a significant positive effect for sleep restriction therapy (d = −0.45; 95 % CI: [−0.63; −0.36]) was found. Overall, the results suggest that sleep restriction therapy improves self-reported sleep continuity and sleep quality, and stimulus control therapy improves self-reported and objective total sleep time. No significant effects of psychoeducation, relaxation therapy, and cognitive therapy, and no further significant effects of any CBT-I component on objective sleep parameters were found. The most common sources of bias were a lack of blinding, missing outcome data, and the absence of study protocols. The current results suggest that sleep restriction therapy and stimulus control therapy are the most effective components of CBT-I 

lok: 52460272 3

exp: 52460272 3 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.019 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398290 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 5

exp: 52460272 5 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.022 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398304 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 8

exp: 52460272 8 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.025 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398312 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 10

exp: 52460272 10 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.027 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398320 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 11

exp: 52460272 11 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.032 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398339 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 20

exp: 52460272 20 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.034 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398347 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 21

exp: 52460272 21 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.037 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398355 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 23

exp: 52460272 23 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.040 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398363 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 25

exp: 52460272 25 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.043 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398371 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 108

exp: 52460272 108 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.047 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $0128639838X 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 204

exp: 52460272 204 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.050 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398398 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH 

lok: 52460272 205

exp: 52460272 205 1 #EPN
201B/01 $013-12-24 $t01:50:53.052 
201C/01 $013-12-24 
201U/01 $0utf8 
203@/01 $01286398401 
208@/01 $a13-12-24 $bl 
209S/01 $S0 $uhttps://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 $XH

LEADER	00000cam a22000002c 4500
001	524602727
003	DE-603
005	20241213015053.0
007	cr\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|\|
008	241212s2024 xx \|\|\|\| o\| u00\|\|u\|eng
015			\|a 24,O12 \|2 dnb
016	7		\|2 DE-101 \|a 1348592869
024	7		\|a 10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102507 \|2 doi
024	7		\|a urn:nbn:de:bsz:25-freidok-2587341 \|2 urn
035			\|a (DE-599)DNB1348592869
040			\|a DE-603 \|b ger \|c DE-603 \|d DE-603 \|e rda
041			\|a eng
082	7		\|8 1\p \|a 616.84 \|2 23kdnb
084			\|a 610 \|q DE-101 \|2 sdnb
100	1		\|a Steinmetz, Lisa \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)466634218 \|0 (DE-588)1213474116 \|2 gnd
245	0	0	\|a Network meta-analysis examining efficacy of components of cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia
264		1	\|a Freiburg \|b Universität \|c 2024
300			\|a 1 Online-Ressource
336			\|a Text \|b txt \|2 rdacontent
337			\|a Computermedien \|b c \|2 rdamedia
338			\|a Online-Ressource \|b cr \|2 rdacarrier
500			\|a Clinical psychology review. - 114 (2024) , 102507, ISSN: 1873-7811
520			\|a Abstract: Cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (CBTsingle bondI) is recommended as first-line treatment for insomnia. CBT-I is a multi-component intervention comprising psychoeducation, sleep restriction, stimulus control, cognitive, and relaxation therapy. The relative efficacy of its components has yet to be investigated with state-of-the-art meta-analytic methods. PubMed, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, PsycARTICLES, and CINAHL were searched according to a pre-registered protocol using search terms indicative of insomnia and CBTsingle bondI. Baseline-to-post-treatment effect sizes (Cohen's d) were calculated in a component network meta-analysis. Eighty studies representing 15,351 participants (mean age 44.9 years, 70.1 % female) were included. For the primary outcome insomnia severity, a significant positive effect for sleep restriction therapy (d = −0.45; 95 % CI: [−0.63; −0.36]) was found. Overall, the results suggest that sleep restriction therapy improves self-reported sleep continuity and sleep quality, and stimulus control therapy improves self-reported and objective total sleep time. No significant effects of psychoeducation, relaxation therapy, and cognitive therapy, and no further significant effects of any CBT-I component on objective sleep parameters were found. The most common sources of bias were a lack of blinding, missing outcome data, and the absence of study protocols. The current results suggest that sleep restriction therapy and stimulus control therapy are the most effective components of CBT-I
700	1		\|a Simon, Laura \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)460401203 \|0 (DE-588)1205678611 \|2 gnd
700	1		\|a Feige, Bernd \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)37775014X \|0 (DE-588)1094928585 \|2 gnd
700	1		\|a Riemann, Dieter \|d 1958- \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)15273080X \|0 (DE-588)121328201 \|2 gnd
700	1		\|a Johann, Anna \|d 1981- \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)404612482 \|0 (DE-588)1135787646 \|2 gnd
700	1		\|a Ell, Johanna \|e Verfasser \|4 aut
700	1		\|a Ebert, David Daniel \|d 1979- \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)397423942 \|0 (DE-588)112267600X \|2 gnd
700	1		\|a Baumeister, Harald \|d 1974- \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)297900749 \|0 (DE-588)17373104X \|2 gnd
700	1		\|a Benz, Fee \|e Verfasser \|4 aut
700	1		\|a Spiegelhalder, Kai \|d 1977- \|e Verfasser \|4 aut \|0 (DE-603)204465281 \|0 (DE-588)13631998X \|2 gnd
856			\|u https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2024.102507 \|x Resolving-System
856			\|u https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bsz:25-freidok-2587341 \|x Resolving-System
856			\|q application/pdf \|u https://freidok.uni-freiburg.de/data/258734 \|x Verlag \|z kostenfrei
883	0		\|8 1\p \|a maschinell gebildet \|c 0,13883 \|q DE-101
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398290 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398304 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398312 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398320 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398339 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398347 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398355 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398363 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398371 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)128639838X \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398398 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d
924	1		\|9 603 \|a (DE-603)1286398401 \|b DE-603 \|c HES \|d d