Hidden Criticism?
Titel: | Hidden Criticism? : the Methodology and Plausibility of the Search for a Counter-Imperial Subtext in Paul |
---|---|
Verfasser: | |
Veröffentlicht: | [Erscheinungsort nicht ermittelbar] : [Verlag nicht ermittelbar], 2019 |
Umfang: | 1 Online-Ressource (214 Seiten) |
Format: | E-Book |
Sprache: | Englisch |
RVK-Notation: |
·
|
ISBN: | 3161537955 ; 3161537963 ; 9783161537950 ; 9783161537967 |
- Preface
- p. vii
- Abbreviations
- p. xii
- Chapter 1
- Analogy
- p. 1
- 1
- Introduction
- p. 1
- 1.1
- Point of Departure
- p. 1
- 1.2
- Goodenough's Proposal: Veiled Criticism of the Roman Empire in Somn. 2
- p. 2
- 1.3
- Philo's Political Theory
- p. 3
- 2
- Analysis of Somn. 2
- p. 5
- 2.1
- Preliminary Remarks on Procedure
- p. 5
- 2.2
- Somn. 2 and the Allegory of the Soul
- p. 6
- 2.3
- Political Allegory in Somn. 2?
- p. 8
- 3
- Conclusions
- p. 17
- 3.1
- Summary
- p. 17
- 3.2
- Outlook
- p. 19
- Chapter 2
- Approach
- p. 21
- 1
- Counter-Imperial "Echoes" in the Subtext
- p. 21
- 2
- Evaluating Hypotheses
- p. 24
- 2.1
- On the Nature of Criteria
- p. 24
- 2.2
- The Structure of Historical Inferences
- p. 26
- 2.3
- Bayes's Theorem
- p. 27
- 2.4
- Explanatory Potential and Background Plausibility of a Hypothesis
- p. 28
- 2.5
- Background Knowledge
- p. 30
- 2.6
- Comparing Hypotheses
- p. 33
- 2.7
- Conclusions
- p. 34
- 3
- "Echoes" of the Empire
- p. 35
- 3.1
- Hays's Criteria for Identifying Scriptural "Echoes"
- p. 35
- 3.2
- Application to Imperial Ideology
- p. 36
- 3.3
- Methodological Evaluation
- p. 40
- 4
- Excursus: Inference to the Best Explanation
- p. 46
- Chapter 3
- Discourse Context
- p. 50
- 1
- Introduction
- p. 50
- 2
- James C. Scott's Categories
- p. 50
- 2.1
- The Public Transcript
- p. 50
- 2.2
- The Hidden Transcript
- p. 51
- 2.3
- The Hidden Transcript and the Public Sphere
- p. 52
- 3
- Application to the Pauline Letter
- p. 54
- 3.1
- The Pauline Letters as Hidden Transcript in Veiled Form?
- p. 54
- 3.2
- Pauline Letters as Hidden Transcript in Pure Form?
- p. 58
- 3.3
- Conclusions
- p. 65
- Chapter 4
- Roman Context
- p. 68
- 1
- The Public Transcript
- p. 68
- 1.1
- Criticism within the Framework of the Public Transcript?
- p. 68
- 1.2
- Different Objects of Criticism
- p. 70
- 1.3
- Conclusions: Modification of the Object of Criticism
- p. 90
- 2
- Roman Ideology in the Environment of Paul
- p. 92
- 2.1
- Introduction
- p. 92
- 2.2
- Imperial Cults as an Expression of Imperial Ideology
- p. 93
- 2.3
- Other Expressions of Imperial Ideology
- p. 104
- 2.4
- Conclusions
- p. 108
- Chapter 5
- Pauline Context
- p. 110
- 1
- Counter-Imperial Attitude?
- p. 110
- 1.1
- Introduction
- p. 110
- 1.2
- N. T. Wright: The Empire as Oppressor of God's People
- p. 110
- 1.3
- John M. G. Barclay: The Empire as a Consciously Ignored Peripheral Phenomenon
- p. 113
- 1.4
- Evaluation: What is the Real Plight?
- p. 114
- 2
- From Attitude to Expression: Modifications of the Echo-Hypothesis...
- p. 125
- 2.1
- Paul's Personality as Obstacle for the Echo-Hypothesis
- p. 125
- 2.2
- Two Modification of the Classical Echo-Hypothesis
- p. 129
- Chapter 6
- Explanatory Context
- p. 139
- 1
- Introducing Explanatory Potential
- p. 139
- 2
- Establishing Parallels between Paul and the Empire
- p. 140
- 2.1
- Termini Technici
- p. 140
- 2.2
- Chance?
- p. 141
- 2.3
- True and False Alternatives
- p. 143
- 3
- From Intertextuality to Criticism: Neutral Parallel or Antithesis?
- p. 146
- 3.1
- Non-Roman "Echoes" with and without Counter-Imperial "Resonance"
- p. 146
- 3.2
- Imperial References with and without Critical Intention: Neutral Parallel or Antithesis?
- p. 150
- Chapter 7
- Conclusions
- p. 156
- 1
- Summary
- p. 156
- 2
- Outlook
- p. 158
- Bibliography
- p. 161
- Index of Ancient Sources
- p. 181
- Index of Modern Authors
- p. 189
- Index of Subjects
- p. 194